Introduction

We live — and work — in a digital age.

With almost every major business enterprise in the world employing some form of digital technology — and more than half of all U.S. businesses deploying artificial intelligence (AI) in at least one business unit — the pace of change sometimes seems relentless. The developers of these technologies promise huge breakthroughs for public and private use cases while offering improved productivity and financial outcomes for businesses as well as greater flexibility and job satisfaction for employees.

At the same time, workers are deeply concerned about the impacts of these technologies on their jobs and their ability to work effectively and with dignity. While there has been intense recent focus on AI, a broad array of other digital technologies in the workplace are decreasing job quality for low-wage workers subjected to surveillance, work intensification, deskilling, discrimination, diminished autonomy, and a fissured workplace. Importantly, unions are beginning to work with employers to mitigate the risks of digital technologies and maximize the benefits of those technologies to workers when they are deployed.

This report focuses on the increasingly pervasive role that digital technologies play in the workplace and how those technologies may harm workers, especially low-wage workers. It builds on the current work of the Advancing Worker Justice program at the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, which seeks to bring shareholder advocates and allied worker-led and focused organizations together to advance dignity and justice for all working people. The report relies on interviews with 19 organizations in the fields of labor and technology as well as a substantial literature review. The goal is to highlight opportunities for active shareholder engagement with portfolio companies and public policy advocacy. 

The human rights risks associated with the rapid uptake of digital technologies in the workplace warrant increased investor attention and due diligence to promote decent work for all. A recent global survey found that 57% of workers expect AI to change the way they do their current job and 36% expect it to replace their current job. And those changes are likely to most affect those who can least afford it. An analysis by McKinsey, the consulting company, finds that as AI expands further into the workplace, workers in lower-wage jobs are up to 14 times more likely to need to change occupations than those in highest-wage positions, and most will need additional skills to do so successfully. Women are 1.5 times more likely to need to move into new occupations than men.

Further, while tech giants continue to invest billions in AI, some analysts believe the AI hype bubble is deflating, with new research papers “undermining some of the flashier claims about the tech’s capabilities.”  Academic research shows that algorithmic management systems can sometimes work against corporate objectives, with a negative impact on workplace morale and productivity. In 2023, an ICCR investor statement representing $4.5 trillion in investments under management or advisement warned that failing to create workplaces where all workers are engaged and their basic needs are met risks “operational disruptions and costs incurred from high turnover, employee unrest, and labor shortages; reputational erosion and loss of consumer confidence and trust; worsening product and/or service quality; and even litigation and regulatory action.” 

This report calls on investors to take several actions to safeguard portfolios against the risks to business and harms to workers stemming from the deployment of digital technologies.

  1. Actively engage portfolio companies to conduct human rights due diligence before the development and deployment of such technologies and, on an ongoing basis, to identify, address, mitigate, and avoid adverse impacts on their workforce.

  2. Include worker voice in investor analyses and press companies to engage workers in developing strategies for technology deployment, especially by respecting the right to freedom of association and collective bargaining.

  3. Participate actively in efforts to shape legislation and regulation that fosters responsible, human rights-based policies and practices related to digital technologies.

While there is no consensus definition of low-wage work, the U.S. government says a low-wage worker is a person whose hourly wage rates are so low that even if they worked full-time all year their annual earnings would fall below the poverty line for a family of four. Depending on location, the federal poverty line in the U.S. in 2024 was about $30,000 to $35,000.

New research by Oxfam estimates that more than 39 million workers in the U.S. — or nearly one in four workers — are low-wage workers, defined by Oxfam as any worker earning less than $17 an hour. 

Data from Oxfam and other organizations demonstrates that low-wage workers in the U.S. are most likely to be workers of color, women, women of color, and single parents. Workers in traditionally low-wage retail, restaurant, hospitality, and “gig” sectors are also most likely to earn below the living wage.

WORKERS’ RIGHTS IMPACTED BY DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES

Core rights enshrined in the ILO Conventions:​

  • Article 25: Right to an Adequate Standard of Living​

  • Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise, 1948 (No. 87)​

  • Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining, 1949 (No. 98)​

  • Equal Remuneration Convention, 1951 (No. 100)​

  • Discrimination (Employment and Occupation), 1958 (No. 111)​

  • Occupational Safety and Health, 1981 (No. 155)​

  • Promotional Framework for Occupational Safety and Health, 2006 (No. 187)​

Core rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration on Human Rights (1948):​

  • Article 2: Freedom from Discrimination​

  • Article 12: Right to Privacy​

  • Article 19: Freedom of Opinion and Expression​

  • Article 23: Right to Work and Join a Union (also covers non-discrimination and “just and favourable remuneration”)​

  • Article 25: Right to an Adequate Standard of Living​